But having finished this game last week and having a few days to let it sink in, I wanted to add my own two cents as to why this game is such a masterpiece, as well as an improvement over the original in so many ways.
1) Uncharted 2 has great pacing
Uncharted 2 has a great storyline which would make for great summer blockbuster movie. The Indiana Jones Trilogy (I refuse to acknowledge part 4 as part of canon) were excellent summer blockbuster movies. So what does the game and the movie series have in common? A lighthearted adventure that gave the characters room to explore their surroundings, as well as get into all kinds of trouble. Uncharted 2 has a great storyline, but one which gives its characters (and by that, the player) room to explore the different locations, and take in the lush scenery. I mean, I can't count how many times I had to stop and just walk around upon entering a new chapter in the story. Although the game is one grandiose experience after another, I appreciated the times when the game just allowed me to sitdown and look around. Compare this to Killzone 2 wherein it feels like you're just herded from one destination to another.
Best example: Exploring the town in Nepal for the first time. Playing soccer with the kids and pretending to scare them were some of the simplest but most sublime memories in the game.
2) Great, great GREAT dialogue
This is almost too painfully obvious while playing this game, but I thought that Uncharted 2 has the greatest rapport between characters in a videogame ever. There may have been games with better voice acting, but none can touch the chemistry that Nathan, Chloe, Sullivan and Elena have. You know that you've invested heavily in these characters when you have a big smile on your face when you see Sully and his pornstache again for the first tine, or when you're protecting Elena and Chloe from gunfire in a shootout. The dialogue, and how these characters communicate with one another helps to really immerse the players in their world. Great, great stuff.
Best example: One of the standout moments for me was going with Chloe to the top of a building and finding a swimming pool there. In the midst of the civil war going on around them, as well as the huge helicopter stalking their every move what does Nathan Drake do? He goes for a swim, and invites Chloe to go in for a dip. Marcoooooo, Polooooooooo! Hilarious stuff
There are so many more reasons why I love this game, but those two are at the top of my list. Funny how in a game touted for all the action, gunfire and intense shootouts its the simpler moments that I appreciated most. Kudos for Naughty Dog and their knowledge of the different kinds of gamers and what they'd love to play. They sure got me!
